The Creed and core doctrine · Question 12

If you're judged the moment you die, why is there another judgment on the last day?

Abstract watercolor of a lamb where a small light revealing one person's truth leads on to a horizon where all creation grows bright

The question: “What order do the particular judgment, heaven, purgatory, hell, and the last judgment come in?”

The Church's answer: The Church teaches that when a person dies, the earthly journey of accepting or refusing the grace of God comes to an end, and each one receives the particular judgment, meeting the truth of his or her own life before Christ. What follows is heaven with God, purgatory as the purification for entering heaven, or hell, having refused God and neighbor to the very end.

Purgatory is not a second chance at the exam for someone who was not saved, and it is not a hell with a shorter term. It is the final purification that a person passes through — one who died in the grace and love of God and whose salvation is assured — before seeing God fully. The heart of hell is not that God hates someone and enjoys torturing them; it is the definitive separation of freely refusing to the very end the communion with God who is the source of love and life. God predestines no one to hell and desires the salvation of everyone.

On the last day the dead rise in the body and the last judgment takes place. This does not mean that God retries the same case because he did not know it. It is the completion in which what fruit each person's choices left in other people, in history, and in creation comes fully to light, and in which God's justice against every injustice and a love stronger than death are made clear before all creation. Then the kingdom of God appears in its fullness in a new heaven and a new earth.

If they press further: “Can we say that everyone who couldn't believe in a loving God goes to hell?” — no. We can't make light of the weight of freedom that the doctrine warns about, but neither are we judges who know everything about another person's interior life and last moment. The Church prays that no one be lost, and entrusts the dead to God's justice and mercy. Hell must never be handed down easily as a sentence on someone else, or used as a tool for frightening people into faith.

In one sentence: “The particular judgment at death is each person meeting the truth of a life before Christ; the judgment on the last day is the completion in which, with the resurrection of the body, the fruit of every choice and the justice of God come to light before all creation.”